I’ve been an avid follower of Chris Bowers’ demographic analysis since early last year, and today he does a little followup focusing on the congressional popularity gap. His conclusion:
Unless Republicans can find scarier boogeyman, unless Democrats really screw things up beyond even Bush administration levels, and unless Republicans find a way to start appealing to growing demographic groups, then they aren’t going to find a way back to power. Eventually they will pull it off, as Democrats will not govern forever. However, I think the smart money is that they won’t be able to succeed until 2016, or possibly even later.
One of the wacky things one reads in the comment section of wingnut blogs, as well as a common rejoinder on certain cable news shows, is that if the economy continues to tank and Obama forced to own it, than the GOP will be able to mount a comeback during the next election cycle. Indeed, this seems to be the Rush strategy – hope Obama fails, so they can say “I told you so.”
But following Chris’ work, I really think this is optimistic on the wingnuts part. As he points out in today’s article, If you project the demographic trends forward to 2012, Obama’s margin would have been 2.5 points larger – in other words, due to increasing shares of young, non-whites and non-Christians, Republicans have to increase their share just to tread water.
With all this in mind, I’m going to make some predictions.
1) A Democrat will be sworn in as President on Jan 20, 2017, following Obamas 2 terms.
2) The earliest I would even be comfortable predicting a Republican in the White House is 2024.
3) Republicans could get their deficit in the Senate down to 52-48, though I don’t really know how – and they won’t be able to do that until Clinton’s 2nd term (2020).
4) Republicans will never again control the House during my lifetime – or 2050, which ever comes first.
The only caveat to these predictions is if a third party is formed – most likely by disaffected center-right conservatives and independents to rid themselves of the crazy-right. This third-party scenario is only likely if Obama really does tank the economy even more and we have 5 or more years of true depression. Obama will not lose the next election (barring sex scandal) no matter what the GOP does, but if things get bad, I could see a viable third party forming in time for 2016.
These are bold predictions, but given the demographic reality and the fact that it is simply not possible to screw up this country worse than our last President did – I don’t see any pro-active way for the GOP to get back.
One other thing that no one is talking about that will permanently affect the fortunes of the Republican Party is that Obama really is changing the tone of Washington. Maybe not the tone in Washington, but the tone from it. What was the thing everyone noticed about Obamas not-state-of-the-Union speech? That he talked to us like adults. He’s going to do this for 7+ more years. So will the next Democratic President. Since we’ve all pretty much realized that the GOP has nothing to talk about, nothing salient or intelligent to say about anything the unrealized (yet) consequence of this is that the GOP will start to diminish as even as minority voice. You can see it already on the (non-FOX) cable shows – people are less and less willing to take GOP talking points at face value. The longer that people get used to hearing a President and party address them intelligently, the less people will be willing to put up with canned, 30 year-old talking points. Chris Matthews is already pushing back against the crap, others will follow.
The thing is, as bad as it was for the Democrats during the last administration, they never became a strictly regional party. Not so the GOP. Especially if Obama enjoys some sucess in turning the economy around, business might actually come around (doubtfull, but not impossible), and the GOP will be religated to a southern-rump.
Slowly but surely, and I know this is hard for children of the age-of-Reagan to comprehend, the voices of Republicans on the TV will recede and our political transformation will be complete.
Now, before you take me to task for making seemingly out-there predictions, just realize that I could be setting myself up for a gig as a professional pundit in the event I’m spectacularly wrong.